Dr. Payton expected promptness. When he called a meeting, it was clearly understood that it would begin at the designated time and anyone interfering with that would regret it. As the second hand of the clock in the conference room moved toward the top, the door to Dr. Payton’s office opened, and he stepped out. When the second hand passed the ten, he walked through the door of the conference room and shut it behind him. As it passed the eleven, he was sitting in his chair at the head of the table. Without looking up, he shuffled the papers he’d brought with him and checked them over. As the second hand slid into the twelve, he spoke.
“Shall we begin?” He’d practiced this enough times to ensure the timing. He nodded to his assistant, Debbie, and she rose and locked the conference room door. Anyone invited, who wasn’t already there, would have to find out later what went on. If his or her input had been needed, then they would receive a lengthy lecture of the need for punctuality. In this case, all of the participants had arrived well in advance of the designated time.
At Dr. Payton’s left was Randall Rhodes, the University’s Vice President of Legal Affairs. Dr. Payton had insisted on the position when he’d first been hired as president. He’d had to deal with too many lawyers in his last position, who had to learn the basic details of the school every time something came up. Next to him was Armando Ibarra, the Vice President of University Growth. His duties were the marketing of the University to the community, alumni, and other supporters, and making sure the financial support of the University remained at an adequate level. Next to him at the far end of the table was Ruth Davis the Vice President of Academic Affairs.
Across from her, on the right side of the table sat Dr. Payton’s assistant, Debbie, who waited to take the minutes of the meeting. Next to her sat Elizabeth Lacy, the Vice president of Student Affairs. Between her and Dr. Payton sat Ben Lunsford, the Vice President of Business and Administrative Affairs.
“I assume that each of you have had time to study the situation and prepare the needed information as it impacts your area of responsibility,” Dr. Payton said, looking around, “If there are no initial questions...”
“I’m not sure I have all of the details,” interjected Ruth Davis, “Were the police able to shed any more light on what happened?”
“I’ll try to sum up the information I have, for you.” Dr. Payton began, “At approximately,” he paused to search through the papers he had before him, “one-thirty last night, Professor Engstrom and a student he’d been tutoring,” he paused for another quick search, “Janie Daniels, exited the faculty office building by the east door.”
“Is this common practice for professors to be ‘tutoring’ students of the opposite sex in late night meetings?” asked Randall Rhodes.
“I understand your concern there, Randall,” Dr. Payton said looking at him, “but in this instance, given who the professor was, I don’t see that it’s really anything to worry about. But to answer your question, no, it isn’t common practice, and our faculty are warned about such things. But this was a Memorite, and they do things quite differently.”
Randall nodded and frowned.
“To continue,” Dr. Payton said returning to the papers before him, “Professor Engstrom and Ms. Daniels walked toward the administration building parking lot when two of Ms. Daniels friends met them, and the three students went from there to the dorms. A few moments later Professor Engstrom was shot.” Dr. Payton paused for effect. “The students recalled hearing what they thought was a sneeze, which the police identified as possibly a gun with a silencer.”
Gasps escaped a few of those present. They heard some things they hadn’t before.
Dr. Payton continued, “The students also said they saw Professor Walser sitting on the bench located a few feet from where the police later located the shooter’s position.”
Pushing the papers together Dr. Payton lifted them and straightened the edge of the stack against the table in front of him. He set the stack down and crossing his hands, he rested them on the papers.
“Based on this, and other information gathered, the police took Professor Walser into custody early this morning.” He looked around the table. “That pretty much sums it up, oh, and a police detective and an investigator from the Memorite Society are on campus conducting an investigation. They’re looking through Professors Engstrom and Walser’s offices right now, and will be questioning other witnesses later this afternoon.”
“These witnesses will be students, faculty, us?” asked Ben Lunsford.
“I believe they’ve already questioned the students. This afternoon will be a few faculty members,” answered Dr. Payton.
“Should Randall be there when they are questioned?” Armando Ibarra asked.
Dr. Payton and Randall Rhodes started answering at the same time. Dr. Payton motioned for Randall to continue.
“That really wouldn’t be appropriate. I’d be representing the University, and if any of the faculty members were actually being accused of anything, they’d need their own attorneys present. As far as I know, the police believe they have the guilty parties.”
“Parties,” asked Elizabeth Lacy, “There are others involved?”
“Well,” Dr. Payton answered, “several students were also arrested. It’s not really clear why. The media has assumed it’s in connection with the murder, but I’m hearing from other sources it was because they hassled the police last night when the crime scene was being secured.”
Armando Ibarra hunched forward on his elbows and shaking his head, let out a long sigh. Several others began to look uncomfortable as well.
Sitting back in his seat, Dr. Payton quietly brought both hands palms down on the table in front of him. “Having established that, let’s continue with our reason for being here. I need to know how this will affect each of you, in the area you are responsible for. Let’s start with you, Randall.”
Seeing that all eyes were on him, Randall began. “There are a lot of unknown factors for me to conclude anything specifically. But looking at the various possibilities...” he paused and leaning back in his chair he crossed his arms and absentmindedly massaged the back of his left arm with the fingers of his right hand. “I wasn’t able to find out if Professor Engstrom has any family. I called the Memorite Society, and they politely assured me that they would handle that. If he does have family and they want to sue the University, they would also have to sue the Memorite Society, especially if Walser turns out to be the shooter. That would benefit us because the bulk of the kind of work needed to be done in defending a case like this is precisely the kind of thing Memorites do easily and quickly. On the other hand, if it can be established that the University allowed an environment that drove Walser to do such a thing, then...” He shook his head.
“What do you mean, environment?” asked Ben Lunsford.
“I...uh,” Ruth Davis began, looking even more uncomfortable; “There were some problems among the faculty, specifically with Professor Walser.”
“What kind of problems?” Randolph asked, sitting forward slowly.
Dr. Payton interrupted, “It seemed that Professor Walser was not very well-liked among the faculty, and several faculty members took efforts to make his stay here...less than pleasant.”
“Like what?” Randolph grabbed the arms of his chair with both hands and looked around. He was now almost sounding angry.
“There were quite a few complaints, all petty, but numerous. I referred them to Professor Engstrom, and as I understand it, he took disciplinary measures against Professor Walser.”
Randolph looked at each person. Ben was frowning. Elizabeth was looking at Dr. Payton intently. Debbie was writing furiously. Ruth was staring at the table in front of her, avoiding eye contact, and Armando was leaning on his elbows with his hands in front of his face almost as if he were praying. His chin rested on his thumbs, and his head shook back and forth slightly.
“This is just wonderful news,” Randolph said sarcastically.
“But the guy’s a Memorite, aren’t they supposed to be trained for stuff like that?” asked Ben.
“I have no idea whether they’re trained for that or not,” replied Randolph, “but it’s entirely beside the point. Our worry isn’t about anybody proving anything, but about them making it look like we are culpable. If they can do that, then we’re looking at a hefty settlement to avoid protracted legal fees.”
“Okay,” said Dr. Payton, “Obviously the legal aspect is pretty much open-ended for now. Let’s move on. Armando, what about your end?”
“Well,” he said running his finger through his hair, “I made a few phone calls this morning to sort of...well, get a feel about how people are perceiving this thing, and the response was positive, but with a little bit of uncertainty. In the end, it will depend on whether the tragedy is viewed as just another unfortunate accident that happened to take place here, or indicative of problems at the University. We can work toward encouraging the first view if we can avoid any lawsuits. Mostly people are waiting to see what happens. Fortunately, we have enough of a good reputation that few people are jumping to any negative conclusions, but it would be nice to maintain that reputation and not let this incident tarnish it.”
“Good,” said Dr. Payton, “I’m glad you’re on top of things. Ruth, Elizabeth, do you have anything to add?”
“Well,” Elizabeth began, “the students seem to be coping with the tragedy fairly well. There are those that see it as just another thing to entertain them, and there are those who are demonstrating actual grief. So far the grieving students are handling their emotions. Those I’ve spoken with were encouraged by the decision to not cancel classes. It demonstrated that the University valued Professor Engstrom’s input, and gave them something to hold on to.”
“Well,” Dr. Payton added, “it’s good that Ruth talking me into doing that. I’m glad it’s helping the students.” The truth was, Dr. Payton was ready to cancel classes when several students asked him not to. He spoke with Ruth who simply went along with the idea. But Dr. Payton could tell that Ruth was feeling low after it became known how the faculty had treated Walser. She needed the encouragement. Besides, thought Payton, it was as much my responsibility for Walser’s treatment as anyone else. Ruth cheered up somewhat and gave Dr. Payton a smile.
“Ruth, how about you?’ Dr. Payton asked.
“Well, the faculty are telling me that today has not been a very productive day so far since too many students are preoccupied. But,” she paused, “it’s being driven home to many students the lessons Professor Engstrom tried hard to teach them. I’m seeing a lot of students re-evaluate their study habits and their priorities. While they may have paid a little attention to Professor Engstrom’s ideas before, now they are listening hard. I think we’ll see a dramatic improvement in grades as the semester progresses. Academically, we could use this incident to encourage better study habits. I’d like to see if we could get the Memorite Society to send us a Memorite of the same caliber as Professor Engstrom, who could build on the respect he left.” Ruth paused, looked at the table, and in a quieter voice said, “I think Professor Engstrom would be delighted that he could serve the students in such a way.” She looked up to see all the others staring at her. She wondered if she sounded mercenary or respectful. She’d spent enough time with Engstrom that his raw pragmatism had rubbed off on her. Slowly the others nodded or smiled their approval, and she felt better knowing that they understood as well.
“So, all in all, what I’m hearing is that it’s more or less a waiting game for now,” Dr. Payton concluded, “Is that right?”
A chorus of nods and monosyllabic grunts of affirmation swept the group.
Clasping his hands in front of him, Dr. Payton looked at them and said, “Well, if that’s it, then let’s get back to work.”